| 1-1 | –The Little Mermaid* | Joy To The World |
| 1-2 | –Grease* | Jolly Old St. Nicholas / Up On The Housetop |
| 1-3 | –Monty Python's Spamalot* | It Was Simple Then |
| 1-4 | –Mamma Mia* | My Gift |
| 1-5 | –The Drowsy Chaperone* | Drowsy On Christmas Day |
| 1-6 | –Hairspray* | Tracy Turnblad's Big, Bad Holiday Rap |
| 1-7 | –The Color Purple* | Angels We Have Heard On High |
| 1-8 | –Young Frankenstein* | O Come All Ye Faithful |
| 1-9 | –Rosie's Broadway Kids* | This Little Light Of Mine |
| 1-10 | –Legally Blonde* | Christmas Makes The Whole World Warmer |
| 1-11 | –The Broadway Boys | Hark! The Herald Angels Sing |
| 1-12 | –The Phantom Of The Opera* | Following A Star |
| 1-13 | –Wicked - 1st National Tour* | Mary's Lullaby |
| 1-14 | –The Lion King* | The First Noel |
| 1-15 | –The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee* | 'Twas The Night Before The Spelling Bee |
| 2-1 | –Spring Awakening* | What Child Is This? |
| 2-2 | –Avenue Q* | (At The) North Pole Global Warming Surfin' Party |
| 2-3 | –Curtains* | The Monotone Angel |
| 2-4 | –Jersey Boys* | Dominick The Donkey |
| 2-5 | –Mary Poppins* | Two English Carols |
| 2-6 | –Xanadu* | Away In A Manger |
| 2-7 | –Altar Boyz* | The Innkeeper's Lament |
| 2-8 | –Wicked* | Jingle Bells |
| 2-9 | –Robbin' Hood* | Deck The Halls |
| 2-10 | –Naked Boys Singing | The Coventry Carol / God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen |
| 2-11 | –Chicago* | Alleluia |
| 2-12 | –A Chorus Line* | Broadway Holiday |
| 2-13 | –Rent* | Go Tell It On The Mountain |
| 2-14 | –Les Miserables* | The 12 Days Of Christ-Miz |
| 2-15 | –Julia Murney, Max Von Essen | O Holy Night |